As-yet-untitled Thursday: Comics Solicitations Decrypted
Thursday, June 11th, 2009
Almost 3 years ago, Yourmomsbasement brought you a controversial view of the truth behind Marvel’s comic book solicitations. This scathing insight can be found here true believer: http://www.yourmomsbasement.com/archives/2005/05/the_truth_about_1.html
Obviously we took some time to finish basking in the glory of our Webshite Award TM nomination, but (although we’ve tried) we can’t rest on our laurels for too long, so we have decided to revisit old ground and put a twist on it to lead to future glory. Look on it as polishing a turd if you will.
This time around, we have been researching into the actual meaning of some of the most common solicitation copy. These can influence your buying habits; with a few words you can be enraptured and drop major bank on product which may not deliver on its promise. In today’s economic climate we know your comics dollar, pound, euro and shekel is important, so to this end we have created this article to help you, the reader, to make an informed choice.
| Solicitation | Implied Meaning | Real Meaning |
| Who is X? | Wow. A new character. You need to be in on this one reader. | Here. Buy this comic. Ramp up those sales for a short term change. It’s no one you know anyway. |
| Who is the new Y? | Wow. Someone else taking on the mantle/wearing the cowl/picking up the shield. You need some of that. | See above. But you know what; we aren’t going to tell you who it is yet. In fact, we may only reveal the identity some time in the future. Or not |
| What does the man/woman named only Z have to do with this? | See, mystery. Named only Z, rather than just plain old Z. What is he/she up to? | We still haven’t grabbed you with this person have we? Okay, one more attempt to boost sales of this flagging title. Christ, don’t make us break out the variants again. |
| Following last month’s shocking reveal… | Wow. What happened last month? I’m going to need to get onboard. | Heh. They’re hooked and maybe we’ll get some re-order action. Win/Win. |
| A Crossover Title Goes Here Tie In! | This may be important in the grand scheme of things. May need to Byrne steal at least. | Yeah. Tentative at best. Man, are we still milking this thing? |
| …and someone dies! | Oh ho! A death you say? Any Giffen JLI characters in the book? | Reminder to release “Dead means dead” memo again. |
| … the shocking revelation… | Could be good for speculators. | Anyone have the number of the New York Times? |
| Guest starring the JLA/Avengers! | Yeah, not falling for that one. | No one will fall for that one. |






Saute the onions in a little olive oil in a pan
Much comics based discussion has been focused on the Justice League of America and its easy to see why. Just a few years ago the series was relaunched on the back of a company wide crossover event, with direction being set by a high profile team including bestselling author Brad Meltzer. However, after Meltzer had built a core team and worked with Geoff Johns to reinstate the annual JLA/JSA meeting – which this time included one of the myriad Legion of Superheroes and as a particular storyline endgame brought back Wally West and his family from their Speed Force exile - he left. Post Meltzer, the series had some fill in writers, but in the main it was left to Dwayne McDuffie to write the book on an ongoing basis.
